Monday, 24 August 2015

Feminism and the Fall


Hello, little friends! I'm back in Bristol between holidays and this is my first post about feminism in the Bible. 

Before I start I’d like you to know that I’m totally aware of the amount of baggage feminism carries with it, so there won’t be any bra-burning or man-hating on this blog. Feminism promotes gender equality not domination, and although it focuses on the empowerment of women much of the time there are also areas where men need to be empowered (for example suicide rates among men are 4 times higher than among women). So I hope I can write this in a way that doesn't alienate anyone, if I do please give me a heads up.


Where better to start than at the beginning? Genesis. The creation story. You’ve probably know it but it may be helpful to refresh yourself (Genesis 2:4 – 25 and 3: 1 – 24, you can search it on the internet if you don’t have a Bible handy).

A lot of elements in this story have been interpreted to show mans natural dominance over woman so let’s explore the main ones.

When Adam and Eve are made it seems pretty clear who’s boss: Adam is made first, Eve is a sort of afterthought, a playmate to keep Adam company, and she’s described as a ‘helper’ in verse 18.

But let’s look at it in more detail. First off, Adam translates as ‘human’, not ‘man’ so it’s been suggested that the act of removing his rib to create Eve was more an act of splitting the first human in two to separate it into male and female. (The Hebrew word for rib is more often translated into the word ‘side’ i.e. half of Adam).

And whether or not you agree with the amoeba theory (as I like to call it) God makes it clear that “it is not good for man to be alone.” In creating the first human alone God shows us that we are incomplete on our own, men and women are equal, complementary and integral to one another.

As for the Hebrew word used to describe Eve (translated as ‘helper’) it doesn’t mean helper like an ‘assistant’ or ‘subordinate’. The word azer k’negdo refers to powerful and vital aid and support. It is used throughout the Bible to describe the role of God himself, notably in 1 John 2:1.

Finally, the relationship between man and woman is really important: it illustrates the relationship between us and Jesus. We need Jesus’ aid and support, he brings life to us as life was brought to Adam through Eve (Eve means ‘life’). Only Jesus can complete us.

The second part I want to address is when Adam and Eve eat the fruit of knowledge. When I was younger I sort of got the impression that Eve (the temptress) was skulking about by herself when the snake shows up. The snake's all like “God’s a bit of an old fart isn’t he? Go on, eat a bit of this fruit.” And Eve says, “yeah I guess you’re right.” She eats the fruit and, having poisoned her own mind, runs off to find her hubby to trick him into eating some too. “hey Adam, fancy a nice apple?” “Have you licked this?” “Nah, I just had a tiny bite to check it wasn’t mouldy (heh, heh, heh).”

This story is wildly inaccurate. First off Adam and Eve were both there when the snake rocks up. Eve is discussing the tree of good and evil with it whilst Adam listens (could this be the first example of a women in leadership?). Genesis 3:6 says “she also gave some of the fruit to her husband who was with her.”

At no point does Adam pipe up “er, babe, maybe this isn’t such a good idea.” He eats the fruit when she passes it to him, so both of them sinned equally.

After this, one of their punishments meant that Adam would rule over Eve from that point onwards. And I don’t think this punishment exclusively affects women, the repression of women in many cultures has caused problems which affect both genders: they are no longer equals and no longer complete one another in the same way.

The creation story shows us that men and women are equal yet display contrasting and complementary aspects of Gods character. God made both genders in his own image so that means that all of us embody God, regardless of our gender, ethnicity, impairments, sexuality, dress sense etc etc.

“When God created human beings, he made them in his own likeness. He created them male and female and on that day he blessed them.” Genesis 5: 1-2



The next post will probably look at Jesus' and how he treated men and women equally (catchy title, I know). Also I’d like to thank the people who’ve told me that they enjoy reading this blog. I really appreciate it!
And the painting at the top of this post was done by a nun at our Lady of the Mississippi Abbey in Iowa, my mum found it on the internet somewhere.

3 comments:

  1. Hey Ellie, good thoughts again. I always get challenged by these meaty topics, so I always like a chance to share ideas. I think you started really well by saying (as the pure definition is) that feminism is not out to promote female interests above male interests. There seems to be a clear argument within some feminist ideology that seeks to usurp the male's position in society. I've gotta say though that I don't think there's a solid argument that proves The Bible supports feminism (as much as it doesn't condemn it either). I think the best way to put it might be that it supports and promotes some ideas within feminism. In both Biblical teaching, as well as in society and culture, we live in a patriarchal society. The idea that man is the head of the household doesn't imply that males are better than females, but that they have different roles, and as God (the Father) desires order and structure within a family unit, it's necessary for establishing someone to take the lead. It's also extremely honouring for a woman to commit to submit to her husband because firstly it shows a great deal of humility to her spouse, but more importantly to God. Sometimes where feminism falls down is that it is too self-focused, on my rights, and my positions. Ultimately, if we seek to find our position in God, these titles are largely irrelevant.

    Galatians 3:28
    New International Version (NIV)

    There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.

    ReplyDelete
  2. hey David, thanks for your feedback, its great to hear a voice other than my own!
    in response to your ideas, i dont think im trying to say that the Bible itself, its writers or its culture support feminism because it was written by people in a patriarchal society. instead im more trying to show that God himself believes in gender equality, but of course his intentions have been twisted by sin and by us.
    men and women having different roles is an idea i totally get and i even believed it pretty strongly for a time during uni. many couples and individuals find that it works for them. however we (particularly within the church) often come dangerously close to allocating roles based on gender alone.
    what im trying to say is that we should search for each persons individual strengths (whether that is in a relationship or in the church) and try to nurture them. when we get hung up on the idea of men and women having separate roles we very often miss the talents of individuals. this also applies to different aged people and personality 'types'. if theres a 15 year old girl in the church who has a talent for speaking in front of an audience, silencing her will cripple not only her but also the whole church

    id also agree that feminsim can be very self focused, i definitely fall for that all the time. and when we seek God we become more ourselves and find out the true talents he's given us.

    thanks again! and sorry if i havent replied to your facebook message... ill go and check that now :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yo yo yo,

    On the patriarchal bit, I'm not sure if my point came across right, but it was just to suggest that now (as well as in Bible times) we have to acknowledge that (even if a person wouldn't agree) society is a patriarchal focused one. However, something that I didn't say in my first post would be that the Bible tells us that is how God intends it.
    -I totally agree with you that God loves (and views) males and females equally :) and that His intentions for us were cast aside at the fall :(
    I think one huge thing that Feminism can get wrong (depending on how people interpet it) is that men and woman are exactly the same as each other-they're not! That doesn't mean one is better or worse than the other, but that there are different characteristics. The Biology is different for a start!

    I honestly believe that it can work that men and women are encouraged within their giftings and skills, and that not be limited by the different roles that God has for them respectively. I think there can definitely be a danger of being too aware of allocating roles based on gender alone in a blanket fashion, but at the same time, it seems clear from scripture that God does allocate certain functions for men and women respectively (right from Genesis onwards).

    Yeah, I totally agree that we should seek to nuture any gifts that anybody would have, whilst utilising them, and practicing them in the way God intended. The Church will always make mistakes because it's full of human beings, but we don't need to lose heart.

    Hopefully that doesn't seem too confrontational, it's not meant to be. It's just that it's interesting to me to explore the big issues! :)

    ReplyDelete